Custom Cookies

Whether you’re celebrating a birthday, planning a wedding or looking to add some one-of-a-kind deliciousness to life’s more memorable gatherings, custom cookies are a wonderful way to keep things fun and original.  At Holy Cow That’s a Big Cookie, we can create custom cookies for any special occasion, holiday or event.  Browse our most popular custom cookie options below or get in touch to discuss your needs.

Birthday Cookies

Perfect for celebrations of any age, our custom birthday cookies are always a guest favorite

Baby Shower Cookies

Looking for a clever option to traditional sweets? Explore custom cookies for baby showers

Graduation Cookies

Our custom graduation cookies are delicious, artistic and sure to inspire the proud graduate

Engagement Party Cookies

Need a fun way to congratulate the couple? Surprise them with custom engagement cookies!

Wedding Cookies

Perfect for receptions, showers and rehearsal dinners, you’ll love our custom wedding cookies

Sports Cookies

From snacks at home to cool tailgating treats, our custom sporting event cookies score big!

Holiday Cookies

Ordering custom cookies for your holiday gathering is a festive way to spread more cheer


At Holy Cow That’s a Big Cookie, our team of artisan bakers impart many years of experience to help you create the perfect custom cookies for your upcoming holiday celebration, function or special event. To learn more, explore design ideas or place an order, give us a call at 585-392-1870 or email our staff through our website’s contact page.

You can order Holy Cow Big Cookies online with complete confidence through our secured online shopping cart, or get in touch with our staff for special inquires, fundraisers and custom orders.

We can be reached by phone at 585-392-1870 or via email through our contact page.