February 27, 2025
There’s nothing quite like biting into a fresh, oversized cookie that’s packed with your favorite flavors. At Holy Cow! That’s a Big Cookie, we bake up giant, gourmet cookies that are perfect for every sweet tooth. But with so many delicious options, how do you pick the best cookie flavor for you? Whether you crave classic chocolate chip, love rich, fudgy chocolate, or prefer a sweet and salty peanut butter delight, we’ve got a big cookie with your name on it!
What’s Your Cookie Personality?
Not sure which big cookie flavor is right for you? Here’s a guide to help you find your perfect cookie match:
- Love the classics? You can’t go wrong with a chocolate chip cookie—a warm, buttery favorite loaded with rich chocolate chips.
- Craving extra chocolate? The double chocolate cookie is a dream for chocolate lovers, with deep, fudgy flavor in every bite.
- Want something colorful and fun? Try the candy explosion cookie, packed with sweet candy pieces for a crunchy, chewy delight.
- Obsessed with peanut butter? The peanut butter explosion cookie delivers bold peanut butter flavor with an irresistible soft texture.
- Feeling adventurous? The over the moon cookie combines unexpected flavors for a unique and unforgettable treat!
Mix, Match & Satisfy Your Sweet Tooth
Still can’t decide? Try a mix-and-match cookie pack to sample different flavors and find your favorite! Whether you’re treating yourself or gifting gourmet cookies, our handmade, oversized cookies are perfect for every occasion.
Big Cookies, Big Flavor—Delivered to Your Door!
Once you’ve found your perfect cookie flavor, it’s time to place your order! You can buy our giant cookies online for nationwide shipping or stop by our location in Rochester, NY, to grab a fresh-baked treat. Whether you need a single cookie, a cookie gift box, or a special order for an event, Holy Cow! That’s a Big Cookie has you covered.